Pacific Book Review vs. Chanticleer Reviews: Indie Review Comparison
Pacific Book Review and Chanticleer Reviews are both professional review services targeting indie authors. The key differences are price, review length, and geographic scope.
Head-to-Head
Feature |
Pacific Book Review |
Chanticleer Reviews |
Cost |
$199 |
$175 |
Review Length |
350+ words |
400-600 words |
Turnaround |
6-8 weeks |
4-8 weeks |
Geographic Focus |
Pacific Northwest regional |
National |
Publication Outlets |
1 regional site |
Multiple outlets + awards |
Negative Reviews Published |
Yes, always |
Yes, always |
Free Submission |
Yes (~40%) |
No |
Key Differences
Pacific Book Review is regional (Pacific Northwest) with good pricing ($199). Chanticleer is national with slightly better pricing ($175 vs $199) and longer reviews (400-600 words vs 350+).
Chanticleer also publishes to multiple outlets and participates in award programs. Pacific's strength is regional relevance.
When Pacific Makes More Sense
- Your book has Pacific Northwest geographic relevance.
- You qualify for the editorial review option program.
- Regional focus matters to your marketing strategy.
When Chanticleer Makes More Sense
- You want slightly lower cost ($175 vs $199).
- You want longer, more detailed reviews (400-600 words).
- You want national audience rather than regional.
- You want award program participation potential.
The Bottom Line
|
Chanticleer is cheaper ($175) with longer reviews. Pacific is regional with a free option. For national reach, choose Chanticleer. For Pacific Northwest relevance or free submissions, choose Pacific. |